eISSN: 3023-6940
  • Home
  • Comparison of the effects of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy and percutaneous nephrolithotomy on renal functions

Original Research

Comparison of the effects of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Lithotripsy and percutaneous nephrolithotomy on renal functions


Bakırköy Dr. Sadi Konuk Eğitim ve Araştırma Hastanesi


DOI :
New J Urol. 2013; 8 (1): 29-33

Abstract

Objective: To evaluate and compare tissue penetration depths of monopolar TURP, bipo-lar TURP and 120 W Lithium triborate (LBO) laser in human prostatic tissue.

Materials and Methods: 39 patients sche-duled for transurethral prostatectomy were di-vided to 3 groups, nonrandomly. In monopolar group (group-1) and bipolar group (group-2) prostate was resected by electrocautery and co-agulation was applied for 1sec and 2sec. Resec-ted tissue samples were examined histopatholo-gically. In group-3, following prostate vaporisa-tion and coagulation by 120 W Lithium tribo-rate (LBO) laser, TUR were performed for tis-sue sampling and histopathologic examinati-on. Composed coagulation zones were detected and compared.

Results:  Resection groups, mean values   than the other groups, 1 second and 2 seconds after the process of coagulation coagulation zo-nes were compared in all groups formed by the LBO laser coagulation, monopolar and bipo-lar TURP zone depths were found to be statis-tically significantly higher. The difference bet-ween monopolar and bipolar TURP groups was not statitistically significant (p>0.05).

Conclusion: Termal injury in the surroun-ding tissue generated by 120 W Lithium tribo-rate (LBO) laser reached to deeper layers com-pared with termal injury of monopolar and bi-polar TURP. This effect may obtain better ho-meostasis, visualization and lesser blood loss nevertheless periprostatic structures may be negatively affected. These effects should be evaluated with better histologic identificati-ons and there is need for advanced studies evaluating erectile func-tions objectively.

Key Words:  bipolar cautery, BPH, 120 W Lithium tribora-te (LBO) laser, monopolar cautery, transurethral prostatic surgery.


Abstract

Objective: To evaluate and compare tissue penetration depths of monopolar TURP, bipo-lar TURP and 120 W Lithium triborate (LBO) laser in human prostatic tissue.

Materials and Methods: 39 patients sche-duled for transurethral prostatectomy were di-vided to 3 groups, nonrandomly. In monopolar group (group-1) and bipolar group (group-2) prostate was resected by electrocautery and co-agulation was applied for 1sec and 2sec. Resec-ted tissue samples were examined histopatholo-gically. In group-3, following prostate vaporisa-tion and coagulation by 120 W Lithium tribo-rate (LBO) laser, TUR were performed for tis-sue sampling and histopathologic examinati-on. Composed coagulation zones were detected and compared.

Results:  Resection groups, mean values   than the other groups, 1 second and 2 seconds after the process of coagulation coagulation zo-nes were compared in all groups formed by the LBO laser coagulation, monopolar and bipo-lar TURP zone depths were found to be statis-tically significantly higher. The difference bet-ween monopolar and bipolar TURP groups was not statitistically significant (p>0.05).

Conclusion: Termal injury in the surroun-ding tissue generated by 120 W Lithium tribo-rate (LBO) laser reached to deeper layers com-pared with termal injury of monopolar and bi-polar TURP. This effect may obtain better ho-meostasis, visualization and lesser blood loss nevertheless periprostatic structures may be negatively affected. These effects should be evaluated with better histologic identificati-ons and there is need for advanced studies evaluating erectile func-tions objectively.

Key Words:  bipolar cautery, BPH, 120 W Lithium tribora-te (LBO) laser, monopolar cautery, transurethral prostatic surgery.